Best 4 Slice Toasters – Top 5 Picks for 2019

This is our official list in search of the best 4-slice toaster on the market today. Scroll further down for full details on each product.

5 Highest Reviewed 4-Slice Toasters to Consider


Today’s toasters do much more than simply toast. Wider slots make them ideal for preparing thicker types of breakfast foods such as sourdough breads, English muffins, and bagels. In fact, many of the new wide slot toasters include special features just for toasting bagels. They allow one to evenly brown the cut edge while simply warming the underneath.

In addition, one can find reheating and defrosting options that are well suited for families who often use their toaster for frozen waffles and pastries. Additional features like removable crumb trays and cord wraps make these appliances convenient as well as functional.

When shopping for the best 4 slice toaster, one will find many designs offering extras that make toasting easier. LED screens simplify the settings, and countdown timers help the average home cook coordinate breakfast with ease. High lift levers raise the toast up out of the toaster so the bread can be removed without the risk of burning one’s fingers, and many of the housings remain cool to the touch.

There are even toasters that will raise the bread for viewing without interrupting the programmed settings. The following information highlights the top five four slice toasters currently on the market.

1.) Cuisinart CPT-440 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-440

The Cuisinart CPT-440 is a modern looking toaster with a stainless steel exterior that includes special features such as the motorized lift. The backlit blue LED function display screen allows one to program the exact settings they want easily while showing a countdown timer.

Enhanced bagel toasting browns the cut side while warming the bottom, and the cancel, reheat, and defrost options make this appliance quite versatile. It takes up a minimum amount of counter space when not in use due to the easy cord wrap, and a three year limited warranty is included in the purchase price.

PROS

  • Includes a Motorized Lift In Order To Remove Bread Safely
  • The LED Display Screen Comes with a Countdown Feature
  • Includes a Defrost, Reheating, and Cancel Feature as well as Bagel Toasting Settings
  • Three Year Limited Warranty Included

CONS

  • Does Not Include a Removable Crumb Tray for Easy Clean-up

($) Check price on Amazon

2.) Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster

Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster

The Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster has 1 ½ inch wide slots that easily accommodate thicker breakfast breads such as waffles, bagels, and hand slices bread. The multi toasting functions allow one to perfectly toast each item. The frozen feature is ideal for frozen items.

It allows extra time when toasting so that everything comes up at the desired brownness the first try. If not, the automatic toast boost will give the bread that extra needed toasting time. All of this is accomplished while remaining cool to the touch.

PROS

  • 1 ½ Inch Wide Slots That Accommodate Thicker Breads
  • A Cool Touch Exterior Provides Extra Safety in the Kitchen
  • The Two Crumb Trays Make Clean-up Simple
  • The Multi Toasting Functions Allow One to Perfectly Toast a Wide Range of Bread Products

CONS

  • It Does Not Include a High Lift Feature

($) Check price on Amazon

3.) Breville BTA840XL 4-Slice Toaster

Breville BTA840XL

The brushed metal, four slice Breville BTA84OXL Smart Toaster includes an internal chip that regulates the toasting and allows one to lower the bread with a touch of the finger. The “bit more” setting lowers the toast for additional browning while the auto lift and lock raises the bread for viewing without disrupting the settings.

An illuminated LED panel is used to select the required settings, and it doubles as a progress indicator. A beep signals when the toast is ready. It has a 1800 watt heating element, and the wider slots accommodate waffles, thick bread, and bagels easily.

PROS

  • Push button controls and the one touch auto lowering function makes this model easy to operate.
  • Includes 1800 Watt Heating Elements
  • Brushed Die Cast Metal Finish on the Housing
  • Comes with an One Year Limited Warranty

CONS

  • Does not toast evenly when using only one slice of bread

($) Check price on Amazon

4.) KRUPS KH734D 4-Slice Toaster

KRUPS KH734D

The KRUPS KH734D toaster is constructed of chrome and brushed stainless steel. It toasts up to four slices of bread with six browning settings available. This is easily adjusted with the dial setting. The high lift lever makes it easy to remove smaller items without burning one’s fingers, and the reheat and defrost functions ensure consistent results when working with frozen foods.

The self-centering, extra-large slots accommodate bagels, English muffins, buns, and thicker homemade breads. Bagels come out evenly toasted on the cut side while warmed on the bottom with the help of the bagel mode setting.

PROS

  • Self-centering, Extra-large Slots Accommodate Thicker Breads and Bagels
  • Five Function Dual Control Panels Allows One to Select Desired Amount of Browning
  • High Lift Lever Keeps User From Getting Burned
  • Removable Crumb Tray for Easy Cleaning

CONS

  • Sides of toaster can get hot to the touch while in use

($) Check price on Amazon

5.) KitchenAid 4-SliceToaster

KitchenAid 4-SliceToaster

The KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster is a stainless steel appliance with empire red accents. It allows one to toast bread to any desired shade, defrost frozen foods, evenly toast bagels, and reheat items. The extra wide slots can handle English muffins, bagels, and sourdough bread.

Each slot measures 1 ½ inches wide, and the manual high-lift lever makes it easy to access smaller items without getting burned. Special features include the bagel button which reduces the heating elements on one side to 50%, and the adjustable shade control ensures that every item is toasted to one’s exact preferences.

PROS

  • Four Extra Wide Slots to Accommodate Thicker Breads
  • Removable Crumb Tray for Easy Clean-up
  • Cord Storage underneath Helps Keep Countertops Tidy
  • Includes Special Features Such as a Cancel and Bagel Button

CONS

  • Side pieces are constructed of plastic which does not fit in with the all metal design

($) Check price on Amazon

Wrapping Up

The above information will help one find the best 4 slice toaster for their own individual needs. Each one of these appliances includes attractive features that make toasting breads convenient and simple. The wide slots accommodate everything from regular sliced bread to thick bagels while toasting evenly on all sides.

Jump back to comparison table ↑